Showing posts with label American Politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label American Politics. Show all posts

Saturday, January 2, 2010

Re: The Cash Committe: How Wall Street Wins On The Hill



The HuffPost has an article showing how deep an impact campaign financing has on legislation. While the effect is well known if not always fully acknowledged, the report describes the workings of the House Banking Committee and analyses the behavior of people who compose its membership recently.

Whether you are a conservative or a progressive on economic matters, and whether you agree or disagree with a piece of financial reform or another, two conclusions can be made on the workings of the legislative process from the article.

First, the banks and other financial interests have an advantage in influencing policy at the committee level, not because their ideas are fundamentally better, but because they have more money to contribute to the election and re-election of legislators and can have a strong influence on their career and personal wealth. Second, it corrupts the democratic process because people who got elected running a progressive campaign fail to accurately represent the mandate they got once they are placed on those committees aggressively targeted by lobbyists.

There is, however, some major saving points for the legislative process as a whole. First and foremost, if the more vulnerable committee members are ready to step on their party line for personal advancement, their leaders are ultimately more accountable to their constituents and have the power to rein in members who went astray - and given the ire of the population over big banks and the financial meltdown last year, they have every incentive to do just that since many of their seats will be up for re-election next year. Second, anything that comes out of a committee then has to go through the House and then the Senate where people who were shut out of the process have the power to defeat an outrageously left or right bill.

Nevertheless, the corrosive effect of campaign financing and personal advancement alluded to in my previous post (see Senate Reform and the Source of the Problem) is real and is brilliantly documented in this article.


Here are my notes.

- Many legislators will seek to join a "money committee" instead of another because "joining [one] makes fundraising, especially from donors with financial interests litigated by the panel, significantly easier". Members of money committees are particularly vulnerable to lobbyist pressure. "It creates a culture where people don't have to show up... You just show up to vote... " says freshman Rep. Jackie Speier (D-Calif.)

("Money committees" include the banking committee chaired by Barney Frank as well the tax-policy-writing Ways and Means Committee and the Energy and Commerce Committee.)

- The Steering and Policy Committee assigns seats on the money committees in particular to "frontline members" who need financial bolstering in states that are likely to be hotly contested during the next election. "As a result, leadership made a choice to prioritize fundraising over the passage of strong legislation."

- Legislators and staffers lack experience and knowledge of what they are suppose to legislate on. Those members "don't understand what it is they're tackling -- though they might be able to repeat talking points from lobbyists." ""What they know is people," says a former staffer."

- There is cohesion between the career of a lobbyist, that of a legislator and that of their staff, which further raises questions of conflict of interests (despite a bar of one year for a staffer to join a lobby group). "According to a HuffPost analysis of the 243 people who've worked on the committee -- including clerical and technology staff -- since 2000, almost half of the 126 people who have left registered as lobbyists, mostly for the financial services industry." "Cashing out is using your position to get a significantly greater salary in the private sector," says Ventrone, who now works for the National Association of Realtors.

- This creates a lack of representation for the interests of the general public, and can corrupt progressive politicians. "But then again, banks and other financial interests can afford an army of aggressive and well-connected middlemen, while consumers groups are left with one or two sentries to cover two chambers. It can mean the difference between winning and losing."

- In politics, nothing is ever simple and the strategy of some democrats of voting with the banks could backfire. "But is it all that pragmatic? Waffling centrists can have a hard time holding on to their seats -- especially when a populist wave comes washing over, wiping out pandering politicians. And by pushing for Washington to go soft on Wall Street, the frontline Democrats -- and the leadership that put them there -- have helped create the very storm that could carry them away."

Monday, December 28, 2009

Senate Reform and the Source of the Problem

The increasing polarization of the American political system and the efficiency - or lack thereof, of passing policy is a subject of interest to me.

Ezra Klein has been following that trail and collected his thoughts on the topic this Sunday. Click here.

The main ills of the system are the following:
the absence of bipartisanship, the use of the filibuster to obstruct progress rather than protect debate, the ability of any given senator to hold the bill hostage to his or her demands

In Brooks and Shields last Friday, one of them stated that the number of times a filibustering attempt was made this year exceeded that of the whole decade of the 1960’s.

As a result, bills are focusing on the “low hanging” fruits instead of tackling problems more comprehensively and fixing politically difficult yet important problems. The benefit of the population and the general interest of the state are left to suffer.

This here is the best line of the article:
The government can function if the minority party has either the incentive to make the majority fail or the power to make the majority fail. It cannot function if it has both.

What this translates into is an inability to legislate effectively because the minority party increasingly wants to see the majority fail and has the power to make it fail. As a consequence, filibustering and other delaying tactics means more time is spent doing less things. If the tendency is maintained, the American legislative process is facing paralysis.

It puts the American political system at a disadvantage when faced with other, nimbler political systems, such as better functioning democracies, or, for that matter, authoritative China. (See here my post contrasting the US and the Chinese political systems in their capacity to take on the challenge of developing and implementing new Energy solutions)

This is not to say that America should repaint itself with an autocratic brush; rather it should seek the following, which is how the system was meant to work:
a world in which the majority can pass its agenda is a better one, a place where the majority party is held accountable for its ideas and not for the gridlock and inaction furnished by the Senate's rules.

But short of phasing out filibustering, or implementing a regressive majority threshold - two measures being suggested here and there, I am skeptical that America can get away without making other reforms in other facets of the American political system. This is because the ills of the democratic political system in America lies not in the Senate procedures: rather, the amount of filibustering and partisanship are symptoms of an increase in the power of public opinion, and, at the same time, of the system of electoral financing.

There used to be a time when Congress – and for that matter, their western equivalents, were truly representative: legislators were elected and then went to their Houses, Congresses and Assemblies where, by and large, they were free to confer with their peers and make legislation. Today, because of the explosion of media coverage, politicians are never completely done with campaigning. While there was certainly bickering in the past, compromises and cooperative actions were possible. Today, those are seen as giving in and as political defeats.

Secondly, it used to be that being a public servant was a duty of the higher class of society: doctors, lawyers, and the educated elite that were already rich. There was an ethic of service and an Enlightenment-inspired  duty towards reason that is now greatly lost. Today, politicians are there to cater to the interests of their campaign financiers and constituents, and very little temperate reasoning is left after they have gone through their campaign rhetoric aimed at manipulating the population into voting them into office. The legislative houses are no longer refuges of reason, but stages from which the elected members project their spin. Furthermore, political success is now a way to pursue personal monetary gains, which was certainly not the case in the past but creates conflicts of interest (a public servant is there to serve the public).

I am not advocating a return to past institutions: such change would be anachronistic. But establishing the differences between past and present, and seeing why the rules were working then and not so much now can be enlightening. Another important factor only alluded to here is the homogenization process in successive stages of the two main political parties since the Civil War.

Political reforms are perhaps the hardest things to do for any regime. Reforming part of the american legislative process will certainly be hard in the current context where any bill one party puts forward will undoubtedly be seen through the very same partisan lens it is trying to mitigate. But as the Ezra Klein piece mentions, the first problem a drunk must fix is not one of the biggest he faces – his debt, the loss of his family, etc, but the seemingly lesser one that is the fact that he drinks every night. Likewise, before America can tackle the problems of tomorrow, it needs to fix its very ability to tackle problems efficiently, which is the growing troubles with the legislative process.

Wednesday, December 23, 2009

The failures of the legislative process

In the wake of growing entrenchment of partisanship in american politics, and, as we speak, in the denouement of the health reform bill, concerns about the efficiency and the soundness of the american legislative process are rising.

Here's a quick piece striking a conversation on the topic, in particular about changing the majority threshold and how to avoid the repeat of Liebermann-esque or Nelson-esque holdouts.

http://www.marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2009/12/how-to-limit-filibusters.html


Actually, it would be interesting to get some numbers on how easily or not policy was passed 100 years ago or 50 years compared to today, and then, in particular, how easily congress has amended and can amend its own ways going forward.